Director: Martin Scorsese
Year: 1991
Novel "The Executioners" by: John D. MacDonald
1962 Adaptation by: James R. Webb
Adapted by: Wesley Strick
Cinematographer: Freddie Francis
Scorsese actually made a much worse film than the original. The first one may not have been perfectly directed (music cues were too strong for example), but it moved along and created a slowly growing wave of terror that by the end had me on the edge of my seat, screaming at the screen. I think the original ranks up there with The Shining as the two most terrifying films I've ever seen. Here, Scorsese is way too heavy handed for my liking (and I thought the music was too strong in the first one... HA!) and I'm sorry but I just didn't find De Niro anywhere nearly as terrifying as the calm, cool and collected pervert that was Robert Mitchum's portrayal of Max Cady. The terror lies in fearing that a man might rape your wife or daughter... that's what riled me. In this version, the script has De Niro more of an indestructable psychopath bent on biting peoples cheeks, who's desire is to murder, and rape doesn't seem to be his primary interest.
Its interesting that Scorsese made room for Peck and Mitchum in his remake, but maybe that contributed to the way he got distracted from slowly racheting up the fear. Also, the script had some sloppiness to it I thought, with the order of dialogue and events. I don't know why Juliette Lewis has to narrate the beginning and end, and for example, when Nolte gets pissed at the parade and punches De Niro, it doesn't make as much sense, why he's so angry as it did in the first film, when Cady is leering at Bowden's daughter in her bathing suit.
Also, the script tries to build up the tension between Bowden, his wife, and their daughter... but never quite successfully. I think the film worked better when it was just Bowden protecting his wife and daughter. Lots of little things that got on my nerves in the remake, and the more I think about the original, the more I can't wait to see it again.
Oh, and the constant tracking in shots, panning from close up of a detail up to a medium shot and all that just frustrated me and took me out of the experience. I felt there wasn't much rhyme or rhythm to the editing either. Felt sloppy. A lot of the camera angle transitions felt contrived.